by Oak » Sun Nov 08, 2015 11:00 pm
You only get the personal choice to eat them or not if you passed any one of those checks, as that would have clued her in on something weird to be able to make the decision. (Which means that you can still die even if you pass any or all the checks - passing at least one check just gives you the choice to not die). Without any of that knowledge, she just goes right to eating 'em. Interestingly, despite teh sheer number of possible skills that can save you on this and give you the choice to not eat them, this is one of the most common deaths for people to get, and for many like you it is their first death. I guess it's the hardest to see coming, since all the skills required are somewhat obscure/ones you wouldn't think of giving her too much in.
Also I've played this before so I've hit a lot of the endings, so I don't know if I should say too much about my own playthrough here. I'm more at the point of outright looking for deaths though to fill my achievement list, since I already have enough of a handle to survive to the end in most cases - though there are still a few achievements/story happenings I need to get to.